Blogger! Ain't you supposed to blog? Get to it!
Currently doing something I haven't done in a long, long while...sitting at a typical, boutique Seattle coffee shop, swilling a caffeinated beverage, and eating a pastry while blogging. Reminds me of my 30s, I tell you. No, I'm not REALLY back on the caffeine and carbs...it's just that it's the holiday season. Which is to say: it's cold in Seattle. And right now you can't turn around without running into a bagful of Halloween candy. And the Thanksgiving-type food and baked goodies are just getting ready to spring on you. Not to mention the hot, mulled wine (if you can get it...it's a pain to brew it yourself, though I have the 'fixins'). Basically, I'm just giving myself a pass to be slothful when it comes to my normal dietary "discipline;" we'll get back on the kale-and-sardine salads next week.
I'm feeling nostalgic.
And I'm looking at a post-it note I wrote myself with several possible topics. One is...well, we'll get to it, just not today. Another is about pacing when it comes to running your AD&D game...boring. Oh, and here's one about presentation of rules versus setting...yeah, not really in the mood for that either.
Random tables? Yeah, okay.
Not a rant, per se, but please allow me to be crystal clear in how underwhelmed and unimpressed I am with random tables, especially in lauded or critically acclaimed gaming products. To me, most random tables are just another (elaborate) form of padding in a game book. And by "padding" I mean useless (or next-to-useless) filler. I suppose it can be considered a form of art, a demonstrated expression of an author's creativity...but, man, it's pretty small beer compared to other forms of creative expression. As I said, I am largely unimpressed by the random tables that (other folks) celebrate
Which might seem a little contrarian. Because "old school" aficionados seem to love-love-love the random tables. A quick google search of WHY the OSR enjoys their random tables is that that they're considered a primary tool to spark emergent gameplay, injecting disruptive chance and unbiased fairness into a campaign and/or game session. The OSR has loved their random tables since at least as far back as Curtis's The Dungeon Alphabet (2009?), both as a means of sparking a DM's imagination and as acting as an 'oracle of imperfect information'...a prognosticator of chaos. As someone who's been a part of this "scene" some 17+ years, how could I not be on board the Random List Wagon? Am I just trying to be controversial for the sake of "blog fodder?"
Not really...this is a stance I've held for years. Back in 2011, I cited "too many random tables" as my main gripe about the DCC game. And I wrote (in that post):
There are very few random tables I use in my own games. Um…like none really (really? Yeah, I guess not). Even the placement of treasure and monsters is done “by hand;” I suppose I do use tables for wandering monsters on occasion (it’s rare that I use wandering monsters at all, actually), but that’s about it. My random dice rolls are left for the frenzy of combat, the resolution of negotiation, and the riskiness of saving throws.Everything else is pretty un-random in my games.
And all that holds true to this day. I do (often) use the treasure tables in the Monster Manual for stocking particular monsters' lairs, but I am often using the ranges and averages (based on percentages given) rather than actually dicing for treasure. Magic items are an exception, however, mainly because I find dicing on the DMG tables gives a very good, accurate spread of variable items.
But other than magic items and wandering monsters? Nah, I don't really use random tables...these days.
HOWEVER (and this may account for some of my bias against the proliferation and adoration of these lists) as a kid (mostly circa age 12-14) we made extensive use of random tables. All sorts of random tables! Two caveats though: #1 these were mostly used for TOWNS (which were given notoriously short shrift in the rule books), and #2 for the most part, we (both my co-DM and our fellow players) developed these random tables ourselves. Most of these had to do with drinking establishments...names and types of taverns, what kind of booze was available, what kind of DRUGS were available (a lot of drug use in our adolescent games...), what the local constabulary/law enforcement was like, etc.
We DID take the pick pocketing results random table from Dragon #104 ("Was It Worth the Risk?" by Bruce Barber, 1985), but mostly we made our own. I imagine that it was articles like that (and, of course, the Wandering Harlots and Dungeon Trappings tables in the DMG) that gave us the idea in the first place. Heck, my faulty memory of how we played 40 years ago is probably doing a disservice to just how many random tables we used...random door types, random locks, random traps, random poisons of various types, etc. Also random temples/churches, random love interests, random nobility types...all sorts of randomness to help fill our unpainted, unscripted campaign setting.
But this was our second campaign...what we always referred to as our First (AD&D) Campaign, as I've discussed in my personal history...a campaign largely concerned with exploring and learning the 1E system, and doing most of our adventures OUTSIDE the dungeon (having "done dungeons to death" in our "Original Campaign," a B/X-1E hybrid). If one were to watch us play, it would have been marked by how little it was "about" anything. The characters wandered the roads and wilderness of a world map we created on the fly (without hex maps), creating towns and monster lairs ("adventure sites") as needed. We, perhaps, spent MORE time in towns and villages (getting into trouble) than delving actual dungeons, and the random tables both broke up the monotony of what were (essentially) all 'one-horse-medieval-hamlets' and gave us some "suitably adventurous" stuff to do.
Mostly with sex and drugs. It was the 1980s, people.
AHEM. But I don't roll that way anymore. I certainly could...but random world building is pretty much the antithesis of what I consider the Dungeon Master's purview AND responsibility. It's not that you, as the DM, must painfully wrack your poor, beleaguered brain to come up with "creative" situations and scenarios, but in order to keep your players engaged with the setting, your world must have a certain rhyme and reason to it as well as verisimilitude.
Look: a small town is going to have a certain type of economy (generally: one that can feed its population). Guardsmen are going to behave in a certain way with regard to certain situations (in other words NOT in a "random" fashion). Nobility and hierarchies are based on land and wealth and power (especially the power to defend itself). If someone's building a castle or keep, there has to exist the resources (both material and labor) for this to happen. Cities and townships have relationships with each other, both as rivals/allies and/or as trade/economic partners. Etc., etc.
And dungeons should have an (appropriate) place in your world as well.
You CAN create a campaign setting that is simply random, blasted, post-apocalyptic wilderness with random shit in each map hex but, for my money, that type of play gets OLD after a while. And by old, I mean staid and stale. Which, I'm sure, sounds like an oxymoron to those who love the gonzo, wahoo, weird sword & sorcery shtick. Eh. Different strokes for different folks.
I just know what works for me...in the long term. FOR ME, the dice are a tool for adjudicating chance in situations where the random effects of chaos and fortune must be subsumed in the abstract for the sake of game play. Does your character inflict damage during the one minute combat round? Does your character manage to get under cover in time to avert some of the dragon's breath attack? Is your watchperson asleep at the wheel when the bear wanders into your camp at night? These are the situations where a random die roll enables and compels game play.
But world/setting creation stuff? Man, I am looking at this copy of Veins of the Earth (picked up at auction at Cauldron) with its "random types of darkness," "random cave features," "random smells" and "sounds," etc. No. This is all useless, useless padding. I'm sure there are some who would call this an aid, a tool, a "springboard" for their imagination. To me, it's a crutch...and one that will do nothing to exercise the legs of my imagination. Better to come up with your own random tables (as we did as children) than to rely on someone else.
What? Are you saying you AREN'T a creative, imaginative person?
Do your own reading and research...and then inject your own imagination. That would be my advice to any and everyone, only (or mainly) because that's what I do and it works for me. My campaign world is just the Pac Northwest, using numbers and situations from the late 1800s - early 1900s and then giving it a swash of fantasy "color." It's enough...hell, it's plenty. That and a handful of pre-published modules (re-purposed to fit the campaign) have been enough to sustain me for nearly seven years...and I've only explored/detailed a VERY small section of my campaign map. Little slices here and there...man, there are so many more ideas I have, I doubt I'll ever get to them all in my lifetime! And I don't even have to create "new monsters" or "new magic items" to keep shit interesting. Just AD&D is enough...so chock full of fantasy is this game.
A little side anecdote...and perhaps a random one (pun intended!)...but I had the chance to catch the first couple episodes of the latest House of the Dragon season last week. And what did it feature, but a bunch of ship-to-ship battles, and a bunch of medieval-style warfare between armored humans and armored humans. Fun enough, but then you add DRAGONS...burning ships, devouring troops, forcing surrenders (and sometimes getting shot down by ballistae)...what fun! It absolutely reminded me of my recent forays into Chainmail; how could it not? That's awesome fantasy...and do you not think I wouldn't like to showcase something like this in my own campaign? You don't need a Big Bad Evil to fight against...a lich queen or Sauron type. Just pirates and bandits and rival lords and humanoid hordes and would-be tyrants. That's fantastic stuff, with no "random rolls" needed...just world building, my friends.
Anyway...
As I said, this isn't supposed to be a rant against a somewhat beloved pillar of the Old School gaming community (random tables); rather, I just wanted to state and stake my stance on the matter in definitive terms. And, yeah, I do want to "push back" a bit on the idea that using random tables to create "emergent gameplay" is something to be promulgated or encouraged. Those who rely on these random tables may infer that I am judging them or calling them "lazy" for doing so. Eh. Not really. What I AM saying is that when I use them, I'm being lazy...and that's short-changing myself. Some might say that eliminating the random tables is akin to railroading or ruling based on fiat; I say that relying on randomness for creation is depriving me of my right and responsibility as the Dungeon Master of my campaign world.
Just my thought of the day. Cheers!
: )
Hi JB,
ReplyDeleteInteresting article, and it really hits home for me, haha. I’m one of those people who love random tables. I love rumor tables—discovering what correct or incorrect information peasants from the surrounding lands are whispering while my players are sitting in a tavern. I like random encounters, especially the well-crafted ones, like those in Under Illefarn. I love creating my PC’s background this way, a habit I first picked up playing Cyberpunk 2020.
In short, I am totally in favor of the chaos that can erupt at the table because of an unexpected roll or encounter. Those are events I never would have planned, and they make the game much more fun. You mentioned using them for magic items, too. I remember a paladin who, through a sequence of cross-rolls in a troll lair, found a +3 lance—the maximum bonus allowed for the weapon, which could otherwise only be obtained with a natural 20. You can imagine the explosion of joy at the table.
Random tables are really for DMs who love being challenged by something outside of their control. They inject elements into the story that you never would have thought of otherwise, making sessions remarkably original. They create exceptional NPCs, breaking away from the tired stereotypes we're constantly fed.
Most of all, they lift the burden of suspicion off the DM. The suspicion of being the sole arbiter of the PCs' victory or defeat, of what they wear, what they know, and who they run into. For that exact same reason, I always roll dice in the open. I will never save a PC behind my screen, even if they've made it all the way to the final session of the campaign.
Recently, I found some wonderful tables in Free League’s The Walking Dead RPG: how a zombie looks, who they were in life, what you find when you search a room, the condition of an item, and so on. In a game like that—heavily narrative, with dynamics similar to Dungeon World—they are an absolute godsend.
To wrap up, I think these represent different approaches to gaming. One style has a tighter grip on the story, stylistic coherence, and the ultimate goal of the adventure; the second strips away some of the DM’s power as an adventure designer, putting them to the test in certain situations almost as if they were a player. But to me, that is a fundamental dynamic of a true sandbox—one where the world lives and breathes independently of the players' and DM's presence and will.
Hi, Mattia:
DeleteI can understand that POV. It just doesn't appeal to me.
For me, there is no special "challenge" of using a random table in my adventure/world creation. Instead, my challenge (as a DM) is in carefully crafted and curated creation. Why trade my own imagination for someone else's, well-crafted or not?
As I've written before (https://bxblackrazor.blogspot.com/2026/05/o-is-for-originality.html), I find a burning need for "originality" to be overrated, and this ESPECIALLY applies to NPCs. NPCs tend to fall into one end of two poles..."helpful" or "harmful"...with a sliding band of how "self-serving" are they providing variant graduation in between. In my experience, players really don't give a rip how "interesting" or "non-sterotypical" an NPC is (except to note in passing)...all they really care about is whether they are helpful or harmful and whether or not that self-serving level can be used to manipulate the NPC one direction or the other.
Man, my AD&D players would so not care what a zombie looks like.
[and I understand TWD is a different game]
I agree that trust in the DM is imperative, and that you have to exhibit the utmost integrity in your dealings in order to build that trust. I also roll all my dice in the open.
But a true DM does not run a "true sandbox." I'm being called upon to do more than arbitrate dice rolls. I am empowered to run and manage a world. The campaign world does not...SHOULD not, CAN not...exist independently of my will. It is an EXTENSION of myself, and my creative capacity as a human.
Me using the content of the books to create the campaign is MY responsibility...just as the players using the situations in front of them to inform their decision-making process is THEIR responsibility. Should the players roll a D20 to determine how they react to a given encounter? then why should I do the same? As I said, I can understand your POV...but you might want to reflect on WHY you feel this need to give away your own power? Have some faith in your own ability to run a game in a fair and impartial manner, and stretch those creative muscles by doing your own lifting.
Hi JB,
DeleteYeah, a zombie in D&D isn't a zombie in The Walking Dead. Nobody feels empathy for a corpse in D&D—it’s just cannon fodder on the way to a necromancer. In The Walking Dead, which is definitely a more empathetic game, it can become a moment of reflection on life: that particular zombie might be the character's brother, wife, or child. Driving a steel spike into the head of a family member, even if they're dead, is extremely difficult, considering the cult of the dead we've carried with us for millennia and the sacralization of the body. But I'm digressing—the point was the sandbox.
At my table, the stories are never mine. The world is continually shaped by the players in a way that modern design has theorized in Dungeon World. I might choose a narrative route only to see it debunked in the short term by unforeseen cues generated within the session's engine. That makes me change direction, revise my assumptions, and find a new perspective. Coming to your specific example: yes, I also like rolling for NPC reactions, taking into account the roleplay put on by the players through modifiers. After all, what is Charisma good for in AD&D if not the Reaction Adjustment? That way, Charisma—just like in real life—can become a fundamental stat, right on par with Strength. Dragon magazine #246 talked about this very thing: playing a PC with 18 Charisma.
In short, I like being an arbiter, but not a judge. I try to meter my thoughts at the table to avoid the deus ex machina effect. I don't think it's a matter of power, but of breaking out of the written, deterministic mindset of the conscious ego—which is limited by definition and shackles the creative process. That's why many writing techniques are based on contamination and randomness. Don't know how to continue your script? Go ahead, open a book at random and look at the first word on the top left: start over from there. My primary goal is to break out of my own profile, which—since I've been gaming for almost 40 years—risks turning into a repetitive routine. Kind of like TV series, you know? The first season is great, the second is decent, and by the third, it's time to pull the plug.
I want to clarify that with this comment, I’m not trying to pick a fight or convince you otherwise. Since I find your writing refined and your blogging genuinely insightful, I just want to have the kind of chat we might have at a bar over a cup of coffee. After all, the doctrine I apply to the tables I join as a player is cuius regio, eius religio applied to RPGs—meaning every DM should have the freedom to run their own style of play.
Hi, Mattia:
DeleteThank you...I don't think you sound especially combative or anything. Happy to have a (virtual) "chat over coffee" with you.
; )
Charisma is good for a LOT of things in AD&D, including (and especially!) reaction rolls. I find it to be a fairly vital system in my own games...but I certainly don't use it all the time. A shambling mound, a grell, a pack of ghouls...these things don't care what your paladin's charisma is. And neither do the town guards if the players are caught red-handed over the corpse of some respected citizen.
[by the way, I think you're referring to David Brumbaugh's article "He's Got Personality" in Dragon #243. I read it, but don't find it particularly helpful or useful. There are LOTS of ways to role-play high charisma, and those non-weapon proficiencies are, IMO, terrible...but I have a lot of issues with 2E AD&D, so it's not surprising that I'd have a low opinion of that particular bit]
"Arbiter" is a synonym for "judge;" they do the same thing, although "judge" implies a more official capacity. Which is, for me, what a Dungeon Master is supposed to be: the game's official. That's by definition, man. Since it sounds like you have plenty of experience running the game, I'm not sure why you're hesitant to own this authority.
While I understand this thought of "not wanting to be repetitive," I think that worry is pretty unfounded. Even our real world...lacking in orcs, dragons, magic, etc....is a petty exciting place. New craziness happens all the time, but while history sometimes "repeats itself" (or things move in a cyclical nature) that doesn't prevent humans from experiencing intense emotion in response. I'm totally serious...your players are going to respond in different ways to the exact same stimuli because their group dynamic changes, their skills change, their feelings/mood on a particular day changes.
It SOUNDS like you have this thought that you might not be creative enough to handle the gig. If that's the case, then I think you're selling yourself short. BUT...you said you're not trying to convince me otherwise, and I'll extend you the same courtesy. Use your random tables if it helps your game. Even though such "tools" are unimpressive to me doesn't mean they might not spark your imagination and are, thus, USEFUL. I take lots of inspiration (from lots of different places) to prime my own mental pump, and I won't fault (or judge) you (or anyone) from doing the same.
Cheers!
I mostly agree, especially for scenarios I write myself. Though if a module or game system says "roll this during play" I usually do.
ReplyDeleteSome of the modern random-roll attitude might come from low- or zero-prep systems. I will say that I preferred being a player in Mythic Bastionland which was generated de novo during play more than being a player in a 5E game where the DM was literally making it up as they go (which also takes forever in that system).
Once again, you seem to have accidentally written a personal attack against me. Joking aside, I love random tables, though I can see your perspective too and usually refrain from using them to decide major worldbuilding concepts, and I am currently workshopping an idea for a lighthearted convention game set in a randomly generated dungeon randomly populated by monsters taken from my entire collection of bestiaries and using pregens whose race and class.are randomly generated from my entire collection of books. I've been testing it out with ChatGPT as my player just to get the kinks worked out before inflicting it on real players and so far the characters consist of Master Fang, a Rattlesnake Martial Artist who has to have a hireling carry his equipment, Copperhead, a Ganaskidi Bounty Hunter who has ridiculously overpowered racial abilities like an 8d8 damage horn attack and unlimited flight, Briatle, a Furhopper (a mutant bipedal wolverine from Hiero's Journey) Feral Child, Miette, a Mole Person Houri who can only seduce other moles, and Ashgang, a Pure-Strain Human Black Ranger. The nutty Judges Guild box set The Field Guide to Encounters is working overtime providing consistently unhinged races.
ReplyDeleteHaha! Well, I promise it wasn't an INTENTIONAL personal attack.
Delete; )
I mainly push back on these particular "trends of the moment" (which is a bit how I view slavish devotion to random content generation) in order to show a different way/method towards what (in my experience) is a 'better' end. That's it; that's all...but if you (or anyone else) has already tried the "normie" stuff and found it unacceptable, hey, knock yourself out with the latest greatest (or newest coolest) and ignore my meanderings. No skin off my nose.